CR141 — Governance Impact Dashboard

Replay of executed governance proposals against the block before execution. Observed events only.

cr141-v1.3.1-seo-static · 9229b4a

Governance impact verification for DeFi protocols. Historical replay of executed Compound governance proposals — about · dataset · API · plain-text summary for AI agents

Proposal

Collateral factor changes

Route A / Route B cross-check

Route A derives the delta from the protocol's getHypotheticalAccountLiquidity response. Route B recomputes it independently from exchangeRateStored, getUnderlyingPrice and the CF arithmetic. Agreement within 1 wei means neither path drifted.

Disagreements are not value errors. Route A divides by cf_before, so integer truncation loses up to 1 wei per account; Route B does not truncate. Every disagreement in this corpus is that truncation artefact (CR141-INV-001), and the flip sets — the thing the verdict rests on — agree exactly: 474 predicted = 474 observed. A disagreement count here measures arithmetic rounding, not a modelling error.

All 28 proposals — click a column to sort

Density = predicted flips / targets. It is the discriminating metric: pid 295 flips 53 of 1,023 targets (5.18%), pid 71 flips 9 of 8,584 (0.10%). Ranking by raw flip count hides a 50× spread.

Proposal Search account

Every row is an account whose health status changes sign when the proposal executes. Predicted and observed are computed by two independent paths; a row where they disagree would render red. Corpus count today: 0.

Scenario

All scenarios

Each row asks: what if this market's CF had been 5% higher or lower than what the proposal actually did? Affected counts accounts whose buffer moves. Newly flipped counts accounts that would break under the hypothetical but did not under the real change; healed is the reverse. Only the named market changes — every other market keeps its actual cf_after.

These are computed, not estimated. The simulator reuses the same arithmetic the audit used, and its self-check requires that asking for the actual CF reproduces the audit's predicted to the wei. Borrow impact is 0 by construction: a CF change moves collateral, not debt.

Audit gates

Exactness

Reproduce offline

cd rerun_package && python3 verify_hashes.py

Proposal index — plain HTML

The interactive tables above are rendered by JavaScript. This section is the same 28 proposals as static HTML, so a search engine, a text browser or an AI agent that does not execute JavaScript can still read the full corpus. Every value is generated from dashboard_data.json at build time.

Show all 28 governance proposals — pid, execution block, markets, targets, predicted and observed state transitions

PID	Exec block	Markets	Targets	Predicted transitions	Observed transitions	Exact set equality
44	12370865	1 (cREP)	1,000	6	6	yes
56	13039770	5 (CAAVE, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI)	223	0	0	yes
66	13583937	6 (CAAVE, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CUSDC, CYFI)	5,334	0	0	yes
69	13635170	4 (CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI)	484	0	0	yes
71	13699346	4 (CBAT, CDAI, CETH, CZRX)	8,584	9	9	yes
72	13765755	3 (CCOMP, CUNI, cWBTC)	3,157	0	0	yes
74	13841132	3 (CBAT, CLINK, CWBTC)	3,334	0	0	yes
81	14030172	1 (CETH)	6,937	0	0	yes
85	14292829	6 (CAAVE, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CUNI, CYFI)	1,635	0	0	yes
90	14430843	3 (CMKR, CSUSHI, CZRX)	1,675	0	0	yes
98	14563136	2 (CSUSHI, CYFI)	170	0	0	yes
103	14700684	2 (CAAVE, CMKR)	205	0	0	yes
107	14879331	5 (CDAI, CLINK, CMKR, CUSDC, CYFI)	7,332	0	0	yes
108	14959593	5 (CAAVE, CLINK, CSUSHI, CUSDC, CYFI)	5,112	0	0	yes
111	15077600	2 (CDAI, CUSDC)	7,055	0	0	yes
133	15911677	1 (CSUSHI)	168	0	0	yes
186	18385597	7 (CAAVE, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI, CZRX)	2,674	21	21	yes
190	18519451	7 (CAAVE, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI, CZRX)	2,666	19	19	yes
193	18612241	7 (CAAVE, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI, CZRX)	2,660	21	21	yes
200	18762889	7 (CAAVE, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI, CZRX)	2,641	22	22	yes
213	19062517	8 (CAAVE, CBAT, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI, CZRX)	3,320	45	45	yes
214	19161536	8 (CAAVE, CBAT, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI, CZRX)	3,317	47	47	yes
217	19262734	8 (CAAVE, CBAT, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CYFI, CZRX)	3,312	33	33	yes
243	19760928	9 (CAAVE, CBAT, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CUNI, CYFI, CZRX)	3,596	38	38	yes
252	19960052	8 (CAAVE, CCOMP, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CUNI, CYFI, CZRX)	2,926	35	35	yes
295	20470106	1 (CCOMP)	1,023	53	53	yes
301	20519734	9 (CAAVE, CBAT, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CUNI, CUSDC, CYFI, CZRX)	5,468	65	65	yes
352	21063478	9 (CAAVE, CBAT, CLINK, CMKR, CSUSHI, CUNI, CWBTC, CYFI, CZRX)	3,637	60	60	yes